Guthly vs Hevy: Gym Workout Tracker Showdown
Hevy is a rising star in workout logging with a social twist. Compare it with Guthly's comprehensive tracking ecosystem.
Guthly Team
Product Team
If you're serious about the gym, you've probably heard of Hevy. It's one of the most popular workout trackers with a loyal community and a slick social feed. But how does it compare to Guthly, a platform that goes beyond the gym to track your entire personal development journey?
Hevy nails workout tracking with clean UI, exercise templates, PR tracking, and a social feed where you can follow friends and share your lifts. Guthly matches the core workout tracking and adds habits, nutrition, wellness, and AI-powered insights — all in one platform.
In this comparison, we dive into every key difference to help you decide which app fits your training and lifestyle goals.
Quick Verdict
Choose Guthly if...
- You want workouts + habits + nutrition + wellness in one app
- You want AI-powered insights that connect your training to your lifestyle
- You prefer a more affordable premium plan ($4.99/mo vs $9.99/mo)
- You care about tracking calories, macros, and how nutrition impacts your lifts
Choose Hevy if...
- You want a social gym experience with friends and community
- You love sharing your workouts and seeing what others are lifting
- You only need a dedicated workout tracker and nothing else
- You want a generous free plan for gym logging
Feature-by-Feature Comparison
| Feature | Guthly | Hevy |
|---|---|---|
| Workout Tracking | ||
| Exercise Library | ||
| Workout Templates | ||
| Sets & Reps Logging | ||
| 1RM Calculator | ||
| PR Tracking | ||
| Social Feed & Friends | ||
| Habit Tracking | ||
| Nutrition Tracking (Calories & Macros) | ||
| Mindfulness & Wellness | ||
| AI-Powered Insights | ||
| Advanced Analytics | ||
| Cross-Platform (iOS, Android, Web) | ||
| Dark Mode | ||
| Real-Time Sync | ||
| Free Plan |
Detailed Breakdown
Workout Tracking
Hevy was built from the ground up as a gym tracker, and it shows. The workout logging experience is polished — you get a massive exercise library, customizable templates, rest timers, PR detection, and volume tracking. The UI during a workout is clean and intuitive, making it easy to log sets between exercises.
Guthly offers comparable workout tracking with an exercise library, sets/reps logging, workout templates, a 1RM calculator, and progress tracking. While Hevy has a slight edge in pure gym UX polish, Guthly's workout data feeds into a bigger picture — connecting your training performance to your nutrition, sleep, and daily habits through AI insights.
Social & Community
Hevy has a strong social component. You can follow friends, see their workouts in a feed, like and comment on sessions, and even compare PRs. For gym-goers who thrive on community accountability, this is a major draw. It feels like Instagram for lifters.
Guthly currently focuses on individual tracking rather than social features. There's no workout feed or friend system. However, Guthly compensates with AI-powered insights and comprehensive analytics that keep you motivated through data rather than social validation.
Beyond the Gym
Guthly is where the gap becomes clear. Beyond workouts, you get full habit tracking, nutrition logging with calorie and macro counting, mindfulness and wellness tools, and AI that ties everything together. Want to see how your protein intake correlates with your strength gains? Or how your sleep habits affect your gym performance? Guthly makes those connections.
Hevy is a workout tracker, period. No habits, no nutrition, no wellness. If you want to track what you eat or build daily routines outside the gym, you'll need additional apps — which means more subscriptions and more context switching.
Pricing
| Plan | Guthly | Hevy |
|---|---|---|
| Free Plan | Yes — habits + 1 year history | Yes — generous workout logging |
| Premium | From $4.99/mo | $9.99/mo |
| Premium Includes | Unlimited history, workouts, nutrition, AI insights | Advanced charts, unlimited routines, no ads |
Final Verdict
Hevy and Guthly are both excellent workout trackers, but they serve different needs.
If the social gym experience is what keeps you consistent — following friends, sharing PRs, and being part of a lifting community — Hevy is a fantastic choice. Its social feed is something Guthly doesn't currently offer.
But if you want more than just a gym logger — if you care about tracking your nutrition, building daily habits, monitoring your wellness, and getting AI-powered insights that connect everything — Guthly is the better investment. You get workout tracking that rivals Hevy, plus an entire personal development platform, at half the price.
For gym-goers who see fitness as part of a bigger picture — not just what happens between the squat rack and the bench press — Guthly delivers far more value for your money.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Hevy or Guthly better for workout tracking?
Both are excellent for logging workouts. Hevy has a slight edge in gym-specific UX and social features. Guthly matches the core tracking and adds nutrition, habits, and AI insights. If you only care about gym logging, they're comparable. If you want more, Guthly wins.
Does Guthly have social features like Hevy?
Guthly currently focuses on individual tracking and AI-powered insights rather than social features. If community and sharing workouts with friends is important to you, Hevy has the advantage in that area.
Can I track nutrition in Hevy?
No. Hevy is exclusively a workout tracker. It doesn't offer calorie or macro tracking. You'd need a separate app for nutrition. Guthly includes full nutrition tracking with calorie and macro logging built in.
Is Hevy Pro worth $9.99/mo?
Hevy Pro adds advanced analytics, unlimited routines, and removes ads. It's solid for dedicated gym-goers. However, Guthly Premium at $4.99/mo includes comparable workout features plus habits, nutrition, wellness, and AI — making it better value for most users.
Can I use Hevy and Guthly together?
You can, but it means double-logging workouts or choosing one for the gym. Most users find it more practical to use Guthly as a single platform that handles workouts, nutrition, and habits together rather than juggling multiple apps.
